By Mark Brighouse, Chief Investment Officer
06 March, 2017
What does US$24 billion buy you on the stock market these days? Based on Snap Inc.'s upcoming initial public offering, $24b buys you a company that specialises in disappearing photos, disappearing cash, and most concerning: disappearing shareholder rights.
Snap Inc. is the company behind photo messaging app Snapchat — set up for users to share photos that are self-deleting.
Snap has never made a profit; the company is burning through cash at a rate of around $2 million per day. For every $1 it makes, it spends around $1.14 in cash. The company's revenue is improving as user numbers increase but costs are rising even faster. In 2015, the company lost $372 million; in 2016 it was up to $514 million.
We acknowledge that some companies with a poor profit history turn this around and become great investments — Amazon.com is a fine example of this. What we really object to in this float are Snap's nonexistent shareholder rights. This is the first time in US history that a company has listed shares with no voting rights. When we say no voting rights we mean none; no single right to influence the future direction of the company in any way.
Founders Evan Spiegel and Bobby Murphy will maintain total control of the company through a unique share class structure. This gives them control over "all matters submitted to our stockholders".
The ability of all shareholders to have some influence over the executives and direction of a firm is fundamental in ensuring that companies are run for the interests of all owners, not just a select few. Snap has disregarded this basic tenet of how public companies have been, and in our view, should be run.
This is a dark day for corporate governance. We will not be buying Snap shares.
Subscribe to receive
our monthly newsletter
Disclaimer: Fisher Funds Management Limited ("Fisher Funds") is the issuer of the financial products referred to on this website. A replacement PDS for each of the financial products is available here and also on the relevant scheme's offer register entry at companiesoffice.govt.nz/disclose. The information, calculations and any opinions on this website are based upon sources believed reliable, but Fisher Funds, its officers and directors make no representations as to their accuracy or completeness. All opinions reflect our judgment on the date of communication and are subject to change without notice. Professional investment advice should be taken before making an investment. Past performance is not a reliable guide to future performance. A disclosure statement is available from your financial adviser, on request and free of charge.
© 2017 Fisher Funds - Website Design & Development 3webfeet Limited
Is there anything we
can help you with?